What is a Fad?

Seriously, what is it? See, I thought fads were temporary fashions, notions or manners of conduct. Not something you could really apply to anything you’ll be doing everyday for the rest of your life. Like parenting.

But apparently, parenting is a fad, and according to this post on Today Moms, we should all read up on the latest style. In this case, “Detachment Parenting”. Ok, ok, I know this post is written tongue-in-cheek as a response to all the attention attachment parenting is getting lately, supposedly due to this NYT cover(although in my opinion, attachment parenting was doing a fine job garnering attention on its own). And I actually think a lot of what Sarah Maizes says in her piece is funny and true. I certainly share a somewhat similar parenting philosophy.

But that’s just it: it’s a parenting philosophy. It’s not a fad. It’s not going away, any more than my daughter is going away (and I wouldn’t want either of those events to happen!). So if I acknowledge that Maizes is being cute in her writing about so-called Detachment Parenting, then why am I writing about it?

It’s not so much the story itself, which I already mentioned that I can dig. It’s the headline: The latest child-rearing fad? Detachment parenting. It’s meant to get people (parents) up in arms, no matter which side of the fence they parent on. Attachment-leaning parents? Appalled that someone would think of, much less practice or write about, something called detachment parenting. Rolling over and turning off the monitor when the child cries? Abandonment! Allowing the child to sleep in a space separate from the parent in the first place? Unthinkable! (Read my sarcasm here, folks).

And then there are the people who do lean toward a more hands-off, independent style of parenting (again, I mostly identify myself with these people). The very wording: detachment parenting, has negative connotations. I would never go around telling people I’m parenting my child in a detached fashion. Heck, it’s hard enough these days to admit that I’m trying to raise her to be independent. At four months old? Well, yeah, I happen to believe that if I don’t start now, I may never get there with her. I happen to believe that at four months old, she is capable of a certain amount of independence, and I want to encourage that in her. She needs it, and I need it. What’s not to love?

Let me back up a bit by confessing that one of the biggest shocks to me after becoming a mom was how incredibly judgy other moms are. A piece of advice or a sideways glance is often a thinly veiled nod of disapproval. Here I was, thinking that being a mom would be like joining a club of other women who had been there, done that. Well, yeah, it is, but those moms also want to compare and judge all day long. Baby not sleeping through the night yet? One mom told me to put cereal in her bottle. When I explained that I wasn’t against her having solid foods, but only wanted to introduce them with a spoon because that’s how she’s going to have to learn to eat anyway, I felt pretentious. Another mom suggested that she just wanted to cuddle, and I should just get up with her and cuddle, or rock with her, or sleep with her, or quit my job and give her more attention.

Yeah.

The biggest lesson I’ve learned in parenting so far is that you have to know what you believe and stick with it. If you don’t you’re going to spin your wheels, following everyone else’s advice and maybe never finding something that works for you. It’s a reality that, no matter what trick you use for any situation, somebody, somewhere, will judge you for it. Sad, but true. I’ve found that my job as a parent is to stop caring what other people think and just go for it.

So…a parenting fad? Nah. I don’t think anyone really believes that, Today Moms, and I’m not sure, but I think we all see through your attempt to sensationalize parenting choices and put us at odds with one another (again). I do, and I’m not loving it.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “What is a Fad?

  1. A says:

    Great post. As you know, I definitely fall more into the attachment parenting category…but I really, really try not to sound judgy toward parents with different styles! Above all else, I believe that you know your own baby better than anyone else. And I’m also upset by the term “detachment parenting.” It makes me think of someone ignoring their baby and hiding their emotions entirely — which is not at all what you do, or what other “detached” parents do, for that matter. These ridiculous mommy wars…I do wish we still lived in times where becoming a mother meant joining a really cool club.

  2. Richard Magruder says:

    I, too believe that raising a child to think independently is paramount. Good for you! I like your writing style…kinda reminds me of someone else I know…You have given life to the most cogniscent person I have ever been around…she WILL be an independent thinker…and thank you for realizing and facilitating that..she will write in a style that will outstrip the both of us…and damn, won’t we be proud!

    Dad

  3. grassguydave says:

    I read in Freakonomics that it really doesn’t matter how you raise your kids, they are going to be who they are going to be, and to think we can exact our will for them into their lives is naive at best, and probably selfish. I give every ounce of love that I have to my kids, be the best possible person I can be, and make sure they see me a little bit here and there so they know what kind of person I am, and I think they will be allright. I will leave the scriptural references out, but if you raise your kids, and teach them what’s right, they will be just fine. I am glad to see you with a little section of the big block of cheese that is the internet, carved out so you can add your flavor. Thanks for the insight C.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s