Some More Parenting Talk

Happy Mother's Day Mom!

(Photo credit: kevin dooley)

I have covered my thoughts on the so-called “Mommy Wars” before. But today I feel like I need to plead with my fellow moms (at least, the moms of my generation): stop it. Please, please, stop it.

I have not met a mom of a baby or toddler yet who hasn’t personally felt judged by something someone has said about parenting, whether that something was said on TV, in a magazine, or on Facebook (which I am now calling Hatebook, thanks to my blogger hero Jen Hatmaker).  And I’m pretty sure I have all the types of moms in my friend arsenal: crunchy granola moms, moms who formula-feed, moms who let the TV help them watch the kids for a few minutes, moms who cloth diaper, stay-at-home moms (of both varieties – those who do only because they wanted to and those who do because they wanted to and they can’t afford childcare) and working moms (also of both varieties – because they love their jobs or because they need to for financial reasons). Conclusion: no one is immune from this judgy cloud of paranoia and hate.

Case in point:  I saw this graphic on my Hatebook newsfeed the other day.

The mom who posted it loves her kids and wanted to make a point about responsibility. And I think that’s fine. But in doing so, she singled out a lot of her fellow moms, who were quick to point out that some moms have more photos of themselves than their kids for a multitude of reasons, not least of which is that they don’t feel comfortable posting lots of photos of their kids online (we all know that once you post a photo online, it’s there forever in one form or another).  Responsibility is very good. But is there some number of times which a mom is allowed to go out without her kids before she’s considered in the wrong? And if so, I would very much like to know what that number is (sarcasm here).

I think it’s great to be curious about what other moms are doing (i.e.: method of diapering, breastfeeding vs. formula, age at which to introduce solid foods). But within the past few years, I’ve noticed that as a society, we’ve become nearly incapable of sharing our ideas without inflicting judgment on moms who don’t do it our way. And this is so incredibly hurtful.

Something I need to admit to you, dear readers: I struggled with postpartum depression for a few months after Baby I was born (post about that to come). And I can tell you that one of the most crushing, debilitating things a mom who is struggling can hear is that she’s doing it wrong. It still hurts now that that cloud has lifted and I feel ‘normal’ again. I can’t stand it.

It’s just human nature to think that the way you’re doing things is the best way. After all, it’s your best way, or else you would be doing something different, yes? But let me propose something to you:

Breastfeeding moms: smile at a mom feeding her baby a bottle without mentioning that breast is best. Acknowledge that bottle feeding is a bonding experience as well.

Moms whose babies sleep in cribs: high-five a co-sleeper. Toss that crap about safety out the window. Get warm fuzzies when the co-sleeping mom tells you how much she loves waking up next to her baby. Don’t worry about when/if the baby will move to a separate bed later; that’s the mom’s job. Not yours.

Stay-at-home-moms: praise your working mom friends for finding a caregiver for their babies who loves the baby almost as much as they do. Do not remind the working mom that she spends 8+ hours away from Baby every day. Open your mind to the possibility that this separation is good for the entire family. Do not assume that the family could make one income work if they really wanted to. That family is not your family.

Detachment-style parents: help a baby-wearer carry her grocery bags. Don’t scoff at her and assume she can just put the baby down for a second. Entertain the idea that this is the best nap the baby gets all day.

You get where I’m going right? I know, I KNOW that all the moms out there can remember how tough it can be when they’re uncertain of their parenting choices and just trying to make it work. Taking sides in the mommy wars is a way to proudly proclaim to the world the way you do things. If you can’t do that without implying that someone else’s way is second best, I’m asking you to stop. Think. Empathize. Love. Show respect for your fellow mom, no matter who she might be.


6 thoughts on “Some More Parenting Talk

  1. Valerie says:

    *Thumbs up* to you! This post is right on. Maybe it’s the social media thing that has made it so much worse in the last several years. Idk, but it sure wasn’t like this when my daughter was a baby (born in 2000) – at least not online. Although the parenting books WERE around and I read them and I felt horrible…so I STOPPED! The stress magically melted away!! Then storytimes at the library, etc began and it all started up again. Then we began homeschooling, and at first I enjoyed talking to other moms (anyone, in fact, who would talk to me about it because I was so excited!) but then a funny thing was going on – judgement! Judgement about which curriculum you used, which activities you had them involved in, how you taught them to read! I had had enough. No more. NOW I will answer questions when someone asks me something about how we do things, but otherwise I have become very private because you can’t make everyone happy and it’s OK to do things differently than others. I feel good about decisions I make, and I have spent time making them! I know other moms are spending that same amount of time with their decisions. We’re all ok…. 😉

  2. mar says:

    IMO, as soon as you become a parent, you start feeling guilty about something. This is true for most women I know. I totally agree that folks shouldn’t be putting others down for their choices–butt out! But I also see this in soooo many parts of life–what you wear, what you drive, what you eat, do you exercise? The difference is that our children mean soooooo much that all that judgement and guilt hurt more. Just my thoughts. Great post, it is so honest. Keep writing!

    • mar says:

      I forgot to expand on feeling guilty right away–parenting is impossible to be perfect at! If you try to be perfect, that is a problem and by definition, not perfect! There is always something you wish you could buy, or did better, or knew earlier. IMO, the best parents do the best they can with what they have and what they know at the time. I KNOW I made mistakes, but my kids all know I love them–the kids for whom I stayed at home and the one who is a latch-key kid (and I feel guilty about that too!). So, that’s my take. And, again, thank you for being brave and honest. 🙂

  3. Thanks everyone for reading and responding!

    Valerie – I’m so glad this resonates with someone. I know any time a mom asserts her opinion, it can be controversial (even when that opinion is that moms should support one another!) I think your strategy to withdraw from those things that make you feel judged is wise. I have been considering it myself 🙂

    Nichole: Thank you 🙂 I felt empowered when I hit the “publish” button on this one.

    Mar: I agree, the guilt is EVERYWHERE! I think my big problem is with moms who say in one breath that they won’t take part in the mommy wars and that it’s okay to parent however you see fit, and then turn around and post a graphic like the one above for everyone to see. It can be hurtful, and unfortunately, I see it a lot from several different people.
    BTW, I really appreciate your insight on working vs. non-working. I think you’ve done a fantastic job!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s